Response to Wall St Journal Article about Credit Card Processing Fees.
February 13th, 2010
Ms. Ransom,
I had the pleasure of reading your article today. You have successfully illustrated the small business “pains” in accepting plastic – which is a necessary part of business today. Not only does everyone want their “Airline Miles”, but even medical offices are forced to accept credit cards due to our pre-tax flexible spending accounts. Those funds are deposited into bank accounts and participants are issued debit and credit cards to access the funds. Of course, you cannot ignore the fact that a family of four now costs well more than $25 at McDonald’s. There are many reason that credit card usage has increased.
In addition to the increased usage, you have all the new and wild ways the credit card associations come up with for banks to make money so they will keep issuing cards. The most popular was the April ’05 separating of rewards cards. Post April ’05 interchange increased either 11 basis points or 36 basis points (visa) depending on the type of business you own. The biggest issue that Merchants face is NOT the stupid infinitesimal fees that keep coming up, it is how the processors take advantage of how to charge for those fees.
My name is Jeff Tieger, President of Business Advantage Group. I have many years experience in the Merchant Services World. I left the business to use my knowledge of interchange to negotiate FOR my clients as opposed to against them. It is no less than amazing to see the blatant misuse of knowledge in the credit card processing world. I have clients that previously paid 5%, 7%, up to 14% to accept credit cards. Credit Card Processing negotiation is only one of the contingency based services we provide, but since your article is specific and this is my expertise, I will stay focused here as well.
In keeping with my 5 year old example, which still costs business owners way too much, allow me to illustrate how the end user gets taken for a ride. In most cases the pricing structure consists of a base rate (or teaser rate) plus a surcharge for downgrades. A transaction will downgrade for any of countless reasons. In most cases the surcharge for a mid-qualified transaction is 50 to 100 basis points and 75 to 200 for non-qualified. A rewards card can be placed in either of the categories depending on what the processor wants to do…fair right? Theoretically a merchant will pay an additional 50 to 200 basis points for a rewards transaction when it should only cost no more than 36 basis points. How many credit cards out there today are not tied to some type of rewards program?
In your article you cited the example of coffee and a muffin. Both Visa and MasterCard have rates designed for “small ticket” items. The interchange percentage is 10 basis points higher but the flat transaction fee goes from $0.10 to $0.04. The $0.06 is much more important than the 10 basis points (or $0.015 on a $15 transaction). These are just 2 of a million examples of how the processors are a much bigger problem than the associations.
American Express has highly discounted rates for specific industries and it is always suggested that a merchant goes through Amex directly and NOT through their processor. If you do not fall into one of the verticals that Amex offers discounts to, there is not too much you can do. Although some processors are beginning to process Amex now and offer discounted rates to do so. Many processors have been processing Discover transactions for quite some time so those rates have become more controlled as well.
I strongly disagree with one point made in your article. Small business is not left out in the cold to pay higher rates, while the aggressive rates are saved for the Wal Marts of the world. Although that was true as recent as 5 years ago, today you simply need to know what to look for and more importantly, what to ask for. The most immediate opportunity for business owners to control their credit card processing costs, is to understand how it works and negotiate with their processor. Since that is a tall order, there are companies like mine that do the negotiations for them on a contingency basis. Our service will never cost them a dime.
Thank you for taking the time to read my e-mail. Have a great day.
Read the article I commented on. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704094304575029091882451812.html
Jeff Tieger
President
Business Advantage Group
jeff@BizAdvantageGroup.com
